PORTLAND, Maine(AP)
Growing costs and vulnerability to anti-ship missiles sank the
Navy's once-heralded "stealth destroyer," a highly
advanced warship designed to slip close to the shore unnoticed and
pummel targets with big guns.
Faced with cost estimates upward of $5 billion per ship, the
Navy had no choice but to let its prized DDG-1000 Zumwalt destroyer
program end after the first two ships are built, analysts said
Wednesday.
Congressional investigators long had been concerned that the
Navy tried to incorporate too many new technologies on an untested
platform. The originally envisioned 32 ships dipped to 12 and then
seven as costs grew.
"I don't think this thing was a shock because
fundamentally the whole program was a big fat target for many
years," said Jay Korman, defense analyst at The Avascent
Group.
Sen. Susan Collins, a member of the Armed Services Committee,
said Wednesday that the Navy instead plans to build nine more of
its current Arleigh Burke destroyers, possibly with some added
capabilities that went into the newer warship.
The DDG-1000's growing cost came as the Navy is trying to
expand to a 313-ship fleet. Officially, the new ships are to cost
roughly double the $1.3 billion price of a Burke destroyer. But
estimates for the first two run as high as $5 billion.
Loren Thompson, a defense analyst with the Lexington Institute,
said the Navy can't afford the DDG-1000 but it can't afford
to stop building ships, either, if it wants to achieve its
shipbuilding goals and maintain a shipbuilding infrastructure.
Another problem with the DDG-1000 design was its potential
vulnerability. Bombarding the shore with guns is cheaper than using
missiles, but the ship would be vulnerable to attack if it came
within 100 miles of shore to use its 155-millimeter guns, Thompson
said.
"The Navy should have understood a long time ago that
putting a $3 billion destroyer off the coast of a hostile country
so that it could use gunfire was a dangerous proposition," he
said.
Finally, there was no known threat to justify the warship,
experts said.
"Please tell me what this thing would do today, if it were
available in Iraq or Afghanistan?" said Winslow Wheeler from
the Center for Defense Information. "Talk about something
that's totally out of control. This thing is a national
embarrassment, that's what it is."
For years, the Zumwalt has been one of the Navy's prized
programs. It has a low profile and composites in its superstructure
for stealth. It also features a form of electric drive propulsion,
new combat systems and a new hull form.
Displacing about 14,500 tons, the ship is 50 percent larger than
a Burke destroyer but will have half the crew thanks to automated
systems.
"I still believe that the ship offers capabilities that the
Navy lacks and needs, but it's up to the Navy to determine its
military requirement," said Collins, a Maine Republican
Maine's Bath Iron Works, a General Dynamics subsidiary, is
building one of the ships. Northrop Grumman's Ingalls shipyard
in Mississippi is building the other.
Copyright 2008 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.